10 Tips for Writing Engaging Murder Investigation Stories

Murder investigation stories have long captured the imaginations of readers and viewers alike. From classic detective novels to gripping crime dramas on television, the genre continues to thrive. But what separates a great murder investigation story from the mediocre? It’s not just about the crime itself; it’s about the journey to unravel the mystery, the characters involved, and the intricate web of clues that keeps readers or viewers hooked. Whether you’re an aspiring novelist or a screenwriter, crafting an engaging murder investigation story requires skill and attention to detail. In this guide, we’ll explore ten tips to help you create compelling and suspenseful murder investigation narratives.

Develop Complex Characters

One of the fundamental elements of any great murder investigation story is the characters. Your detectives, suspects, and supporting cast should be multi-dimensional, with their own motivations, flaws, and secrets. Give your main detective a compelling backstory, quirks, and a distinct personality. Make sure that even minor characters have depth and contribute to the story’s atmosphere and plot development. When readers or viewers become emotionally invested in the characters, they’re more likely to be engrossed in the investigation’s outcome.

Set the Scene

Creating a vivid and immersive setting is essential for an engaging murder investigation story. Whether it’s a gritty urban environment, a quiet suburban neighborhood, or a remote countryside mansion, the setting should play a significant role in the story. Use descriptive language to paint a picture of the surroundings, and consider how the setting influences the characters’ actions and decisions. A well-developed setting can enhance the story’s atmosphere and add depth to the mystery.

Craft a Unique Murder

The murder itself is the central puzzle of your story. To stand out in a crowded genre, you’ll need to create a unique and intriguing murder. Avoid clichés and tired tropes, and think outside the box. Consider unusual murder weapons, motives, or circumstances that will surprise and captivate your audience. A well-crafted murder should raise questions and leave readers or viewers eager to uncover the truth.

Plant Clues Strategically

A successful murder investigation story is a delicate balance between revealing and concealing information. As the author, you need to strategically plant clues throughout the narrative. These clues can be physical evidence, witness statements, or even subtle hints in dialogue. However, be careful not to make them too obvious or too obscure. Give readers or viewers the satisfaction of piecing together the puzzle while maintaining a level of challenge.

Develop Red Herrings

Red herrings are false clues or misleading information that divert attention away from the true solution to the murder mystery. They are essential for maintaining suspense and keeping your audience engaged. Craft red herrings that are convincing and plausible, making it difficult for both your characters and your audience to distinguish them from actual clues. A well-executed red herring can lead to surprising plot twists and a more satisfying resolution.

Build Tension

Tension is the lifeblood of any murder investigation story. From the moment the crime is introduced, gradually build tension as the investigation unfolds. You can achieve this through pacing, suspenseful encounters, and moments of conflict. Create a sense of urgency that keeps readers or viewers on the edge of their seats, eager to see how the story will evolve.

Develop the Detective’s Methodology

Your detective’s investigative process should be a central focus of the story. Whether they’re a seasoned professional or a novice investigator, explore their methodology, quirks, and unique approach to solving the case. Consider the use of forensic science, deductive reasoning, or psychological profiling to add depth to their character and the investigation itself.

Explore Ethical Dilemmas

Murder investigation stories often present ethical dilemmas for the characters involved. These dilemmas can add depth to the narrative and challenge the moral compass of your detective and other characters. Consider situations where the pursuit of justice conflicts with personal ethics or the law. How do your characters navigate these challenges, and what are the consequences of their choices?

Use Multiple Perspectives

To provide a well-rounded view of the murder investigation, consider incorporating multiple perspectives. This can include the viewpoint of the detective, the victim’s family, the suspects, and even the killer. Each perspective offers unique insights and emotional depth to the story. By delving into the minds and motivations of various characters, you can create a richer and more immersive narrative.

Craft a Satisfying Resolution

The resolution of a murder investigation story is the payoff for your readers or viewers, so it’s crucial to deliver a satisfying conclusion. All loose ends should be tied up, and the true solution to the mystery should be both surprising and logical. Avoid deus ex machina solutions that come out of nowhere, as they can leave your audience feeling unsatisfied. Instead, ensure that the resolution is a culmination of the clues, character development, and the detective’s methodology.


Writing engaging murder investigation stories is a rewarding but challenging endeavor. These stories require careful planning, attention to detail, and a deep understanding of human psychology. By developing complex characters, crafting a unique murder, strategically planting clues, and using red herrings, you can captivate your audience and keep them guessing until the final revelation. Building tension, exploring ethical dilemmas, and using multiple perspectives will add depth to your narrative, while a satisfying resolution will leave your readers or viewers satisfied. With these ten tips in mind, you’ll be well on your way to crafting murder investigation stories that are both gripping and memorable.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *